clipped from: commentisfree.guardian.co.uk   

Sex-change surgery is the modern equivalent of aversion therapy for homosexuals.


My concerns about the increasing acceptance of "transsexuality" as a diagnosis are based upon my feminist belief that it arises from the strong stereotyping of girls and boys into strict gender roles.


During the debate I argued that sex change surgery is modern-day aversion therapy treatment for homosexuals. The highest number of sex change operations take place in Iran, where homosexuality is punishable by death. Sex change surgery, therefore, renders gays and lesbians "heterosexual".


I was outvoted at the end of the debate, but I felt I had done my job. All I intended to do was to ask the questions, "Are we right to support sex change surgery, and is it right to apply a surgical solution to what I believe is a psychological problem?"